Active Roster

Media

Sponsors

View Archive

Like us at Like us at FacebookFollow us on Google+

"Spanking is a useful form of discipline" read the article headline.

CORPORAL-PUNISHMENT

I feel that it is necessary to address one area of “discipline” that is commonly accepted and practiced. Spanking foremost, but any form of pain infliction or the hitting a child with a foreign object, as passive as it may seem.  I decided to write this post (an excerpt from my forthcoming book Discipline For a Change) after reading several comments on a Facebook parenting site I follow where the question was asked what a parent should do when a teen girl came home with hickeys' all over her neck.  The comments were frightening to me.  The ranged from grounding to "Whoop that .....".  I am sure you can fill in the blank with the myriad things that were being suggested.  Then I came across this recent letter to the editor in the Columbus Dispatch (read it here http://www.dispatch.com/content/stories/editorials/2013/10/26/done-right-spanking-is-useful-for-discipline.html )  The headline was "Done Right, Spanking is useful for discipline."

I have heard it said that “they were asking for it”, or “they just won’t listen unless I get their attention.”  First, I have only had one child in my care ever ask for physical punishment and this particular child had come from a home where harsh physical punishment was all she knew.  It was difficult for her to understand the discipline focus of our home and wanted punishment.  For an adult to say that a child is “asking” to be hit or somehow assaulted, speaks to the adult more than the child.  

Second, striking a child, raising one's voice, or in any other way creating distress for the child physically eliminates the child’s ability to see you as a compassionate and caring caregiver without the potential for disorganized perspective of attachment. If the child sees you as potential threat, he will be less likely to come to you when he needs comfort.

Third, and final point. If I strike or forcefully grab my wife, I have committed an arrest-able offense of Domestic Battery.  If I throw something at her or hold an object it could be enhanced to assault.  Why is it then that we feel we are justified in inflicting pain and/or threat of harm/discomfort to our children? There is no magical transition at the age of 18 that makes this illegal and the notion that as long as there is no mark only pacifies the fear of being caught.  A true disciplinarian will seek any other means possible to reach the child and get to his awareness.  If the child has become calloused to the yelling and nagging that he is oblivious to you until you scream, hit, or throw something, than it is time to rethink the pattern that you have trained your child to accept.  To be a disciplinarian is to instill hope and a sense of well being in our disciple, not fear based “respect” that is more about self protection.  My hope is that all readers of this work will find in themselves the disciplinarians that children in our care need.  

By Brett M. Judd LMSW Follow him at Google + at Google

P.S.

Have you joined the other members of our exclusive relationship groups, The Art and Joy of Romance and Marriage, who are learning the secrets to deeper love and better sex?  For less than a couple of lunch dates a month, members receive live, personal coaching on the issues that matter most. If you are not a member,  take a look and enroll NOW  in the monthly tele-class and newsletter coaching clubs to increase your intimacy, connection, sex life, and longevity.  You will not regret it. We guarantee it.

Share: https://romanceandmarriagetoday.steadytide.com/blog/Blog54/Spanking-a-useful-discipline-if-done-right--Or-not

Please sign me up for the FREE electronic version of the newsletter and special reports. I understand I will also receive information about sales and services from The Art and Joy.

You will be added to The Art and Joy's mailing list.

You may also subscribe to the newsletter from An Open Mind Counseling and Neurobalancing.
If you choose to be removed from these lists, simply click to unsubscribe button at the bottom of all emails.

NB-BST Newsletter Enrollees
Email*

* Required field

Quick Links:

Latest News


View Archive